These are members of the Hall of Fame elected as players.
| Hank Aaron | Jerry Adair | Sparky Adams | Joe Adcock |
| Tommie Agee | Dale Alexander | Doyle Alexander | Pete Alexander |
| Dick Allen | Gene Alley | Roberto Alomar | Joe Altobelli |
| Red Ames | Ferrell Anderson | Sparky Anderson | Cap Anson |
| Luis Aparicio | Luke Appling | Ed Armbrister | Richie Ashburn |
| Bobby Avila | Carlos Baerga | Jeff Bagwell | Jesse Barfield |
| Len Barker | Clyde Barnhart | Earl Battey | Buddy Bell |
| Albert Belle | George Bell | Johnny Bench | Al Benton |
| Joe Benz | Dave Bergman | Tony Bernazard | Yogi Berra |
| Dante Bichette | Craig Biggio | Max Bishop | Jim Bivin |
| Cy Blanton | Lu Blue | Vida Blue | Geoff Blum |
| Bert Blyleven | Mike Boddicker | Wade Boggs | Milt Bolling |
| Barry Bonds | Bob Boone | Hank Borowy | Jim Bottomley |
| Ralph Branca | Russell Branyan | Harry Brecheen | George Brett |
| Tommy Bridges | Nelson Briles | Ed Brinkman | Tom Brookens |
| Kevin Brown | Larry Brown | Steve Brye | Bill Buckner |
| Mark Buehrle | Jim Bunning | Jim Busby | Joe Bush |
| Melky Cabrera | Miguel Cabrera | Orlando Cabrera | Dolph Camilli |
| Roy Campanella | Robinson Cano | Rod Carew | Gary Carter |
| Norm Cash | Manny Castillo | Marty Castillo | Cesar Cedeno |
| Spud Chandler | Darrel Chaney | Joe Charboneau | Hal Chase |
| Randy Choate | Bill Cissell | Jim Clancy | Matt Clement |
| Roger Clemens | Ty Cobb | Mickey Cochrane | John Coleman |
| Eddie Collins | Earle Combs | Adam Comorosky | Dave Concepcion |
| Mort Cooper | Harry Coveleski | Stan Coveleski | Billy Cox |
| Sam Crawford | Leon Culberson | Jack Cust | Kiki Cuyler |
| Tom Daly | Johnny Damon | Danny Darwin | Jake Daubert |
| Chili Davis | Jody Davis | Mark Davis | Steve Davis |
| Storm Davis | Rob Deer | Carlos Delgado | Bob Dernier |
| Delino DeShields | Josh Devore | Bill Dickey | Miguel Dilone |
| Dom DiMaggio | Joe DiMaggio | Bill Doak | Bobby Doerr |
| Mike Donlin | Al Downing | Larry Doyle | Dan Driessen |
| Adam Dunn | Ryne Duren | Lenny Dykstra | George Earnshaw |
| Damion Easley | Dennis Eckersley | Carl Erskine | Hoot Evers |
| Buck Ewing | Bob Feller | Wes Ferrell | Dana Fillingim |
| Rollie Fingers | Carlton Fisk | Mike Flanagan | Elmer Flick |
| Curt Flood | Whitey Ford | Bob Forsch | Casey Fossum |
| George Foster | Jack Fournier | Jimmie Foxx | John Franco |
| Terry Francona | Ryan Franklin | Bill Freehan | Buck Freeman |
| Larry French | Frankie Frisch | Tito Fuentes | Carl Furillo |
| Freddy Garcia | Mike Garcia | Nomar Garciaparra | Pedro Garcia |
| Ralph Garr | Steve Garvey | Milt Gaston | Charlie Gehringer |
| Lou Gehrig | Cesar Geronimo | Jason Giambi | Kirk Gibson |
| Norwood Gibson | Tom Glavine | Luis Gonzalez | Billy Goodman |
| Greg Goossen | Joe Gordon | Mark Grace | Curtis Granderson |
| Hank Greenberg | Mike Greenwell | Shawn Green | Bobby Grich |
| Ken Griffey | Burleigh Grimes | Marquis Grissom | Heinie Groh |
| Greg Gross | Pedro Guerrero | Bill Gullickson | Tony Gwynn |
| Harvey Haddix | Bump Hadley | Cole Hamels | Atlee Hammaker |
| Mel Harder | Mike Hargrove | Tommy Harper | Toby Harrah |
| Gabby Hartnett | Jeff Heath | Richie Hebner | Harry Heilmann |
| Todd Helton | Rickey Henderson | George Hendrick | Tom Henke |
| Babe Herman | Billy Herman | Roberto Hernandez | Orel Hershiser |
| Shea Hillenbrand | Eric Hinske | Gil Hodges | Trevor Hoffman |
| Sam Horn | Rogers Hornsby | Carl Hubbell | Tex Hughson |
| Randy Hundley | Todd Hundley | Catfish Hunter | Pete Incaviglia |
| Brandon Inge | Garth Iorg | Bo Jackson | Danny Jackson |
| Joe Jackson | Fergie Jenkins | Jackie Jensen | Derek Jeter |
| Randy Johnson | Walter Johnson | Tommy John | Doug Jones |
| Randy Jones | Sam Jones | Jim Kaat | Al Kaline |
| Eric Karros | Charlie Keller | George Kell | Steve Kemp |
| Fred Kendall | Jeff Kent | Don Kessinger | Harmon Killebrew |
| Dave Kingman | Ian Kinsler | Ron Kittle | Ron Kline |
| Ted Kluszewski | Bob Knepper | Chuck Knoblauch | Mark Koenig |
| Ed Konetchy | Chad Kreuter | Tony Kubek | Duane Kuiper |
| Nap Lajoie | Les Lancaster | Max Lanier | Dave LaRoche |
| Gary Lavelle | Luis Leal | Bill Lee | Johnnie LeMaster |
| Bob Lemon | Chet Lemon | Dutch Leonard | Jeffrey Leonard |
| Jose Lima | Kenny Lofton | Mickey Lolich | Ed Lopat |
| Dolf Luque | Sparky Lyle | Fred Lynn | Ray Mack |
| Greg Maddux | Mickey Mantle | Heinie Manush | Roger Maris |
| Mike Marshall | Dennis Martinez | Edgar Martinez | Pedro Martinez |
| Tippy Martinez | Tino Martinez | Victor Martinez | Jon Matlack |
| Gary Matthews | Gene Mauch | Joe Mauer | Carlos May |
| Lee May | Milt May | Rudy May | Carl Mays |
| Willie Mays | Tom McBride | Brandon McCarthy | Tim McCarver |
| Barney McCosky | Willie McCovey | Ben McDonald | Hank McDonald |
| Joe McGinnity | Tug McGraw | Scott McGregor | Fred McGriff |
| Mark McGwire | Stuffy McInnis | Denny McLain | Don McMahon |
| Mike McNally | Hal McRae | Gil Meche | Mario Mendoza |
| Ramiro Mendoza | Fred Merkle | Irish Meusel | Billy Meyer |
| Stu Miller | Minnie Minoso | Greg Minton | Johnny Mize |
| Randy Moffitt | Bob Montgomery | Harry Moran | Keith Moreland |
| Joe Morgan | Jack Morris | Lloyd Moseby | Wally Moses |
| Don Mossi | Jerry Mumphrey | Van Mungo | Thurman Munson |
| Bobby Murcer | Dale Murphy | Stan Musial | Mike Mussina |
| Buddy Myer | Rocky Nelson | Graig Nettles | Hal Newhouser |
| Bobo Newsom | Joe Niekro | Johnny Niggeling | Otis Nixon |
| Jim Northrup | Ron Northey | Lefty O’Doul | Jose Offerman |
| Rowland Office | Ben Oglivie | John Olerud | Tony Oliva |
| Al Oliver | Paul O’Neill | Magglio Ordonez | Al Orth |
| David Ortiz | Mel Ott | Jim Palmer | Milt Pappas |
| Lance Parrish | Monte Pearson | Roger Peckinpaugh | Orlando Pena |
| Herb Pennock | Tony Perez | Gaylord Perry | Johnny Pesky |
| Dan Petry | Ken Phelps | Tony Phillips | Mike Piazza |
| Juan Pierre | Joel Pineiro | Lou Piniella | Vada Pinson |
| Eddie Plank | Bill Plummer | Biff Pocoroba | Dan Porter |
| Darrell Porter | Jorge Posada | Kirby Puckett | Albert Pujols |
| Dan Quisenberry | Tim Raines | Pedro Ramos | Willie Randolph |
| Jeff Reardon | Pee Wee Reese | Merv Rettenmund | Mark Reynolds |
| Jim Rice | Sam Rice | Gene Richards | Jose Rijo |
| Mariano Rivera | Mickey Rivers | Eppa Rixey | Andre Robertson |
| Brooks Robinson | Jackie Robinson | Alex Rodriguez | Francisco Rodriguez |
| Ivan Rodriguez | Pete Rose | Edd Roush | Schoolboy Rowe |
| Dave Rozema | Vern Ruhle | John Russell | Reb Russell |
| Babe Ruth | Nolan Ryan | Chris Sale | Jarrod Saltalamacchia |
| Ryne Sandberg | Pablo Sandoval | Manny Sanguillen | Johan Santana |
| Hank Sauer | Wally Schang | Curt Schilling | Boss Schmidt |
| Mike Schmidt | Hal Schumacher | Everett Scott | Joe Sewell |
| Gary Sheffield | Ted Simmons | Ken Singleton | Bill Skowron |
| Jim Slaton | Roy Smalley | Al Smith | Lee Smith |
| Lonnie Smith | Duke Snider | Tris Speaker | Chris Speier |
| Paul Splittorff | Ed Sprague | Mickey Stanley | Mike Stanton |
| Casey Stengel | Rennie Stennett | Vern Stephens | Tim Stoddard |
| Champ Summers | B.J. Surhoff | Gary Sutherland | Bruce Sutter |
| Don Sutton | Ichiro Suzuki | Craig Swan | Frank Tanana |
| Carl Taylor | Chuck Taylor | Dummy Taylor | Joe Taylor |
| Birdie Tebbetts | Kent Tekulve | Gene Tenace | Mickey Tettleton |
| George Theodore | Frank Thomas | Gorman Thomas | Roy Thomas |
| Tommy Thomas | Jim Thome | Bobby Thomson | Jeff Torborg |
| Joe Torre | Mike Torrez | Alan Trammell | Pie Traynor |
| Hal Trosky | Fernando Valenzuela | Jose Valentin | Dazzy Vance |
| Johnny Vander Meer | Jason Varitek | Hippo Vaughn | Justin Verlander |
| Tom Veryzer | Jim Viox | Billy Wagner | Honus Wagner |
| Gee Walker | Paul Waner | Jackie Warner | Lon Warneke |
| John Wathan | Bob Watson | Earl Webb | Carl Weilman |
| Vic Wertz | John Wetteland | Zack Wheat | Lou Whitaker |
| Frank White | Ernie Whitt | Milt Wilcox | Hoyt Wilhelm |
| Bernie Williams | Billy Williams | Cy Williams | Dick Williams |
| Ken Williams | Ted Williams | Earl Wilson | Hack Wilson |
| Willie Wilson | Hooks Wiltse | Dave Winfield | Rick Wise |
| Jay Witasick | Gene Woodling | Wilbur Wood | Glenn Wright |
| Early Wynn | Jimmy Wynn | Carl Yastrzemski | Steve Yeager |
| Kevin Youkilis | Cy Young | Delmon Young | Ross Youngs |
| Carlos Zambrano | Todd Zeile |