These are members of the Hall of Fame elected as players.
Hall of Famers
| Hank Aaron | Pete Alexander | Roberto Alomar | Cap Anson |
| Luis Aparicio | Luke Appling | Richie Ashburn | Earl Averill |
| Frank Baker | Dave Bancroft | Ernie Banks | Jake Beckley |
| Cool Papa Bell | Johnny Bench | Yogi Berra | Craig Biggio |
| Bert Blyleven | Wade Boggs | Jim Bottomley | Lou Boudreau |
| George Brett | Lou Brock | Dan Brouthers | Willard Brown |
| Mordecai Brown | Ray Brown | Jim Bunning | Roy Campanella |
| Rod Carew | Max Carey | Steve Carlton | Gary Carter |
| Orlando Cepeda | Oscar Charleston | John Clarkson | Roberto Clemente |
| Ty Cobb | Mickey Cochrane | Eddie Collins | Earle Combs |
| Roger Connor | Andy Cooper | Stan Coveleski | Sam Crawford |
| Joe Cronin | Kiki Cuyler | Ray Dandridge | George Davis |
| Andre Dawson | Leon Day | Dizzy Dean | Bill Dickey |
| Martin Dihigo | Joe DiMaggio | Larry Doby | Bobby Doerr |
| Don Drysdale | Dennis Eckersley | Red Faber | Bob Feller |
| Rick Ferrell | Rollie Fingers | Carlton Fisk | Elmer Flick |
| Whitey Ford | Bill Foster | Nellie Fox | Jimmie Foxx |
| Frankie Frisch | Pud Galvin | Lou Gehrig | Charlie Gehringer |
| Bob Gibson | Josh Gibson | Tom Glavine | Lefty Gomez |
| Joe Gordon | Goose Goslin | Rich Gossage | Frank Grant |
| Hank Greenberg | Ken Griffey | Burleigh Grimes | Lefty Grove |
| Tony Gwynn | Chick Hafey | Jesse Haines | Billy Hamilton |
| Gabby Hartnett | Harry Heilmann | Rickey Henderson | Billy Herman |
| Pete Hill | Harry Hooper | Rogers Hornsby | Waite Hoyt |
| Carl Hubbell | Catfish Hunter | Monte Irvin | Reggie Jackson |
| Travis Jackson | Fergie Jenkins | Walter Johnson | Randy Johnson |
| Judy Johnson | Addie Joss | Al Kaline | Tim Keefe |
| Willie Keeler | George Kell | Joe Kelley | King Kelly |
| George Kelly | Harmon Killebrew | Ralph Kiner | Chuck Klein |
| Sandy Koufax | Nap Lajoie | Barry Larkin | Tony Lazzeri |
| Bob Lemon | Buck Leonard | Freddie Lindstrom | Pop Lloyd |
| Ernie Lombardi | Ted Lyons | Biz Mackey | Greg Maddux |
| Mickey Mantle | Heinie Manush | Rabbit Maranville | Juan Marichal |
| Rube Marquard | Pedro Martinez | Eddie Mathews | Christy Mathewson |
| Willie Mays | Bill Mazeroski | Tommy McCarthy | Willie McCovey |
| Bid McPhee | Joe Medwick | Jose Mendez | Johnny Mize |
| Paul Molitor | Joe Morgan | Eddie Murray | Stan Musial |
| Hal Newhouser | Kid Nichols | Phil Niekro | Jim O'Rourke |
| Mel Ott | Satchel Paige | Jim Palmer | Herb Pennock |
| Tony Perez | Gaylord Perry | Mike Piazza | Kirby Puckett |
| Charley Radbourn | Pee Wee Reese | Sam Rice | Jim Rice |
| Cal Ripken | Eppa Rixey | Phil Rizzuto | Robin Roberts |
| Jackie Robinson | Frank Robinson | Brooks Robinson | Bullet Rogan |
| Edd Roush | Red Ruffing | Amos Rusie | Babe Ruth |
| Nolan Ryan | Ryne Sandberg | Ron Santo | Louis Santop |
| Mike Schmidt | Red Schoendienst | Tom Seaver | Joe Sewell |
| Al Simmons | George Sisler | Enos Slaughter | Hilton Smith |
| Ozzie Smith | John Smoltz | Duke Snider | Warren Spahn |
| Tris Speaker | Willie Stargell | Turkey Stearnes | Bruce Sutter |
| Mule Suttles | Don Sutton | Ben Taylor | Bill Terry |
| Frank Thomas | Sam Thompson | Cristobal Torriente | Pie Traynor |
| Dazzy Vance | Arky Vaughan | Honus Wagner | Bobby Wallace |
| Lloyd Waner | Paul Waner | John Ward | Mickey Welch |
| Willie Wells | Zack Wheat | Deacon White | Hoyt Wilhelm |
| Joe Williams | Billy Williams | Ted Williams | Vic Willis |
| Hack Wilson | Jud Wilson | Dave Winfield | Early Wynn |
| Carl Yastrzemski | Cy Young | Ross Youngs | Robin Yount |